For reasons beyond my comprehension, macOS's Disk Utility randomly won't format external drives.
For example, here's what disk utility shows when I first plug in the flash drive.
Here's the error when I try to format it as ExFAT.
Instead, use the diskutil
command to first list
the disks to find out which one is the offending disk disk4
in this case) and then reformat it with something like diskutil eraseDisk [format] [name] [disk]
.